Establishing Textual Authority Essay

Jen n i fer A. Meters o big t t- Smit h

Developing Textual Specialist

and Isolating Voices: A New

Approach to Instructing Referencing


ing is definitely tied to the ability to build textual power. But exactly how address these issues in class?

Over semesters of dialogue

with pupils about the differences

between their very own writing civilizations and

my personal U. T. academic one, I found that

difficulties with referring to are attached to differences in how students examine and write texts. In answer, I

designed a new method to teaching

referring to based on establishing textual power and isolating writers' voices. Because I actually teach make up as

a theme-based training course, my referencing

lessons correspond with theme-based studying

and composing assignments.

In this post, I 1st present a

short discussion of key assumptive

ideas that inform the approach, and

then I explain five lessons, four of

which are integrated into the program

theme of " homelessness. ” There are

many and varied reasons why I use this topic.

Perhaps most critical, I realize that

homelessness, combined with poverty

even more generally, is known as a theme that may be

nowing tips on how to reference

is very important not only to get

students studying in English-speaking countries, but in addition for those who should publish in

English-medium magazines. In many

colleges, however , it is just

assumed that students know how to

reference point, and approaches to teaching referencing are little more than a general public reading with the institution's

plagiarism policy. Because English vocabulary

teachers, we have to take the business lead

in designing a coherent referencing

curriculum to enable our students to

authoritatively quote and paraphrase

so they are better prepared to achieve

all their academic goals.

Ironically, each of our theoretical understandings have far outstripped conventional approaches to teaching referencing. We now know, for instance,

that English language learners by and

large do not plagiarize deceitfully. We

know that using bits and pieces of

other texts may be integral to language

learning. And we know that referenc16



U M W E Ur


At the

N G L I actually S They would




O 3rd there’s r U M

may be accurate for students in the United States

as well as for these from other countries.

The moment, for example , extra students in

the United States browse textbooks, they generally

read to find out material that society looks at

to be accurate. Students are generally not expected to make

distinctions between your positions of numerous

authors for the reason that textbook is normally written by merely one person (who likely did not use details! ).

For a few students, memory also

plays a role in their method of writing. When

they memorize a text, they not only grasp

the content although also what. My Chinese

students want to produce excerpts from

text messaging verbatim as, they believe, the texts are

better worded than their particular writing will

be. Whenever they reproduce a text, they might

experience this as distributed common knowledge,

and so not refer to it. As a result, it is not at all

self-evident to a few students that the idea of

common knowledge does not enable the verbatim imitation of words or knowledge from a text with out appropriate citation.

Furthermore, a lot of students you don't have

experience in recording the positions of various authors in their writing, because they were trained to seamlessly meld the voices of

authority with their own. As one of my Korean language students described, in Korea, she and her classmates " replicated information coming from several

websites, and melded them invisibly. ” This kind of

does not mean that they did not get their

own views, but rather, that they can did not

think that separating out their views

was ideal or critical savvy, or would

have them an A. Since Ramanathan and Atkinson

(1999) explain, pupils from civilizations with

collectivist or interdependent values " learn

to write not so much to present an original,

strong, individual personal, but to display how much...

Sources: Abasi, A. R., And. Akbari, and B. Graves. 2006.

Chandrasoma, R., C. Thompson, and A. Pennycook. 2004. Past plagiarism: Transgressive

and nontransgressive intertextuality

Currie, P. 98. Staying away of difficulties: Apparent

stealing articles and academics survival

Eighner, L. 1993. Travels with Lizbeth. New york city:


Howard, R. Meters. 1995. Plagiarisms, authorships, and

the academic fatality penalty

Kozol, J. 1994. Distancing the homeless. In The

writer's presence: A pool area of works, ed

Pennycook, A. mil novecentos e noventa e seis. Borrowing others' words:

Text, ownership, memory, and plagiarism.

Ramanathan, V., and M. Atkinson. 99. Individualism, academic writing, and ESL writers.

Scollon, R. 1995. Plagiarism and ideology: Personality

in intercultural discourse

Starfield, S. 2002. " Now i'm a second-language English speaker”: Negotiating writer identity and

authority in sociology 1

Tokars, L. (2008). Law enforcement crack down on

drunks in South Bend over

Towson University. 2008. Guidelines affecting pupils: Student academics integrity insurance plan. http://

wwwnew. towson. edu/studentaffairs/policies/